Remember the last time you heated a frozen pizza in your toaster oven? Your expectations were relatively low, but it tasted decent enough. Now imagine if, lined up against a pie from a famous Brooklyn pizzeria, the frozen version comes out the winner.
That's more or less what happened in 1976, in a blind tasting of French and California wines that's since become known as the Judgment of Paris. France had the reputation; California was an unknown entity. All the expert judges were French, and that day they chose California wines as their favorites, unintentionally kick-starting what would become the massive American wine industry.
Were the French judges out of their minds? Not at all, says George Taber, author of the book Judgment of Paris, and the only journalist who attended the '76 tasting (he was a reporter for Time magazine).